10 replies to this topic

[Thugren]

Now, I don't want this to be a flame war, a friendly conversation . Who Was the most loyal primarch, defend with facts not fanboyishness

Sent from my PC36100 using Tapatalk

[Professor762]

The most loyal? I would wager either Guilliman or Sanquinius, leaning more toward Sanquinius since he did give up his life to defend his father against Horus. Many, not all, of the other primarchs did not outright die. Guilliman was suspended in stasis before actual death, others disappeared into the Eye and the Lion died at the hands of his own men.

[Domine Nox]

You would be hard pressed to declare any of the Primarchs that stayed loyal any more loyal than another. They all devoted themselves to the service of the Emperor in their own way, and were unwavering in that fact. No facts can prove more loyalty over another.

[Draco Ny'ade]

i would actually wager pre heresy magnus or sanguinius - magnus was simply trying to find a way to do his duty but unfortuantely became a sorcerer (emperor didnt like that!)

[TheGodDernMan]

The most loyal? I would wager either Guilliman or Sanquinius, leaning more toward Sanquinius since he did give up his life to defend his father against Horus. Many, not all, of the other primarchs did not outright die. Guilliman was suspended in stasis before actual death, others disappeared into the Eye and the Lion died at the hands of his own men.

Lions not dead....

[Romulus_Sorvian]

I am going to Agree with Draco on Magnus, and not because the Thousand Sons are my Favorite Chapter. But because of the lenghts Magnus went to redeem himself before falling to Chaos.

He hid the attack from not only his people but his chapter. Which says alot IMO sense the Chapter had a Bond with one another that differed from others.

And his fall to Chaos was more to protect his people, chapter and knowledge that they had gathered.

But as i said just my options here lol.

[TheGodDernMan]

You would be hard pressed to declare any of the Primarchs that stayed loyal any more loyal than another. They all devoted themselves to the service of the Emperor in their own way, and were unwavering in that fact. No facts can prove more loyalty over another.

I agree completely with the above Nox.

[JC 042]

I would say Alpharius/Omegon, they betrayed the Empra to destroy Chaos, but they technicaly only did it for saving everything, at the cost of the human race, however as they were doing it they were yelling out "For the Empra!" while killing a whole expidition fleet.

[Cypher 1013]

Dorn was as loyal as they come. He returned to Terra even before the heresy allowing his brothers to continue gaining glories. During the heresy the was appointed pretorian of Terra by the emperor given him complete control of Terran's defenses and he never once wavered.

[Gerhart]

Dorn was as loyal as they come. He returned to Terra even before the heresy allowing his brothers to continue gaining glories. During the heresy the was appointed pretorian of Terra by the emperor given him complete control of Terran's defenses and he never once wavered.

Dorn, the truest son. Never was butthurt about being called from the front lines. Always did his duty, and trusted in his father no matter what. Even when others got worried.

[JC 042]

Although to be fair Dorn recieved the least amount of butthurt out of all the primarchs, if not then Guilamen or the Lion.